Questions for you guys

Kirk
whimmy wham wham wozzle!
Kirk's picture
Posts: 294
Joined: 2003-01-02
From: Elgin IL

I'm putting in some stuff to keep out spammers and possible password hackers.  The spam stuff is something you can never get rid of and can be dealt with on a case-by-case basis, but password hackers are another story.  So, in an attempt to protect everyone's accounts, which of the following would you prefer?

  • a CAPTCHA form when you log in, to verify you're a person (the thing with the goofy letter you have to type in)
  • a password policy that requires a new password every X days
  • a password policy that requires a few special things for instance: one capital letter, one number and one non-standard character

 

Next up is the text editor.  I'm intending to switch over to a more "typical" text-editor for you all to use.  Meaning it will essentially be a text-box with a handful of buttons that insert markup tags for you.  Bold and Italics, for example. 

Benefits include

  • Easier to use
  • Less javascript, less potential issues
  • The firefox spellcheck will work
  • potentially faster loading pages
  • resizable text-area

Drawbacks include

  • no what you see is what you get input (can still preview a post before submiting to see how it looks)

If you can provide me with your thoughts on these items, it would be much appreciated.  We have a lot of stuff in the works for the near future, so I'm trying to lay the groundwork.

 



ScribblingDes
Funky Chicken
ScribblingDes's picture
Posts: 1467
Joined: 2007-02-16
From: louisiana
Re: Questions for you guys

 I honestly don't care if someone hacks my cult password and am sick of having to come up with 20 different passwords for different log ins due to the different requirements of various websites.  at least 6 letters, at least 8 letters, at least this many letters and one number at least this many letters and two numbers.  I use the same, simple six letter password for this site that I have been using for everthing that will let me since the 7th grade.  Anyway, I kno other people will feel differently abou this issue... That being said, I still doing like any of the options given.  

My bank does something that I don't really mind so much, it has you set up a security question and it asks you to answer it only if you log in from a different computer.  Of course this would probably be annoying for people who log in both at home and at work.

 

Anyway, has a cult account ever been hacked?

__________________________

"I would never BUY Starbucks coffee grounds since they're popular and I like to hate on popular things because it makes me feel better about my averageness."

--Spike



Kirk
whimmy wham wham wozzle!
Kirk's picture
Posts: 294
Joined: 2003-01-02
From: Elgin IL
Re: Questions for you guys

We've had a few accounts hacked, and every now and again I'll notice someone who is clearly a bot trying lo log in on a random account.  It's not a huge issue, I'd just rather deal with it prior to it happening.  If the general opinion is to not bother, I won't.



ScribblingDes
Funky Chicken
ScribblingDes's picture
Posts: 1467
Joined: 2007-02-16
From: louisiana
Re: Questions for you guys

 gotcha, i'm curious to see how the others feel.

__________________________

"I would never BUY Starbucks coffee grounds since they're popular and I like to hate on popular things because it makes me feel better about my averageness."

--Spike



ScribblingDes
Funky Chicken
ScribblingDes's picture
Posts: 1467
Joined: 2007-02-16
From: louisiana
Re: Questions for you guys

and wouldn't it be great if we still had polls for things like this?!

__________________________

"I would never BUY Starbucks coffee grounds since they're popular and I like to hate on popular things because it makes me feel better about my averageness."

--Spike



Synnove
Synnove's picture
Posts: 2413
Joined: 2006-10-25
From:
Re: Questions for you guys

I prefer this option: 

  • a password policy that requires a few special things for instance: one capital letter, one number and one non-standard character

The odds are pretty good I would forget my password if I had to change it every few days.  and I know some people can't use the CAPTCHA for whatever reason.  My husband had to turn it off on his blog because some people couldn't leave comments.  Now he just has to approve comment and filter spam manually.

 



glamhoth
boo?
glamhoth's picture
Posts: 5836
Joined: 2003-03-27
From: The Hand Mitten. of my heart.
Re: Questions for you guys

 I'd be okay with a CAPTCHA thing (although mostly i just think they're annoying), and the third, more complex password option works for me, but I'd also be okay with not bothering. Definitely not something requiring a new password every X days. that would wreak havoc on my memory banks.

I'm all for the new text box. This one still doesn't quite work as a WYSIWYG anyway, spacing can still be wonky, and changing font size with the drop down menu doesn't work, among other things.



Kirk
whimmy wham wham wozzle!
Kirk's picture
Posts: 294
Joined: 2003-01-02
From: Elgin IL
Re: Questions for you guys

I should clarify, when I said "X days" X would probably be something like 60 or 90.  It's not something you would have to do every week.



glamhoth
boo?
glamhoth's picture
Posts: 5836
Joined: 2003-03-27
From: The Hand Mitten. of my heart.
Re: Questions for you guys

 yeah, i'd still forget it.



ScribblingDes
Funky Chicken
ScribblingDes's picture
Posts: 1467
Joined: 2007-02-16
From: louisiana
Re: Questions for you guys

 any update on the other promised changes?

__________________________

"I would never BUY Starbucks coffee grounds since they're popular and I like to hate on popular things because it makes me feel better about my averageness."

--Spike



Kirk
whimmy wham wham wozzle!
Kirk's picture
Posts: 294
Joined: 2003-01-02
From: Elgin IL
Re: Questions for you guys

I can say that I have some stuff on our test server that will show up here probably this weekend.  Some of which you'll see some of which is behind the scenes.  Mostly minor updates/changes. 

We have some other stuff that is much bigger in progress that will show up once it's done, but is coming along nicely.  For these items, I'll be contacting some members to take a look at in a few weeks (hopefully).

Based on my current schedule, you'll probably be noticing changes of some sort every week or 2.



jane s.
revelling in discomfort
jane s.'s picture
Posts: 20654
Joined: 2003-03-22
From: Florida>Nebraska>South Carolina
Re: Questions for you guys

Synnove wrote:

I prefer this option: 

  • a password policy that requires a few special things for instance: one capital letter, one number and one non-standard character

The odds are pretty good I would forget my password if I had to change it every few days.  and I know some people can't use the CAPTCHA for whatever reason.  My husband had to turn it off on his blog because some people couldn't leave comments.  Now he just has to approve comment and filter spam manually.

 

And by "some people", she means me. I can't hardly read them, it takes me an average of five tries to type them correctly.

 

Also I cannot do Magic Eye things. :(



PocketFives
Taschenfünfer
PocketFives's picture
Posts: 966
Joined: 2006-06-04
From: Gainesvizzle, Floridizzle
Re: Questions for you guys

Everything you mentioned about the text editor sounds great, like steps in the right direction.  I'm completely okay with the preview-before-you-post option if it comes with those benefits.

And I don't know about the passwords.  I think the second option would be the least irritating, though.  I loathe CAPTCHA.



Odegrar
Ulftyr
Odegrar's picture
Posts: 479
Joined: 2008-03-01
From: BAC
Re: Questions for you guys

I don't really care. Choose the one that works best.



labelleza
labelleza's picture
Posts: 1795
Joined: 2007-09-24
From:
Re: Questions for you guys

jane s. wrote:

 Also I cannot do Magic Eye things. :(

!

  • a password policy that requires a few special things for instance: one capital letter, one number and one non-standard character

I like this too I guess. 



Synnove
Synnove's picture
Posts: 2413
Joined: 2006-10-25
From:
Re: Questions for you guys

I can't do those Magic Eye things either!  Also, I can't really get the full effect of 3-D movies.



labelleza
labelleza's picture
Posts: 1795
Joined: 2007-09-24
From:
Re: Questions for you guys

I once saw a barbie movie that came with those 3-D blue/red glasses, and I felt so left out of the fun when everything just looked blurry instead of "leaping into" my living room the way the box promised.



monkeywright
At peace with the Universe....for now.
monkeywright's picture
Posts: 3211
Joined: 2004-12-05
From: SurfMonkeyDesigns.com (Los Angeles)
Re: Questions for you guys

I have a lot of trouble reading the latest version of CAPTCHA (the one that warps the letters). However, if it's a simple two word captcha (like craigslist uses - with REAL words, even!) I'd be for that before anything else. Otherwise, I prefer the 2 digits, mixed case, 1 non-standard character deal.

__________________________


TRANSLATION: I should put your pick in a chinase face reeding sofward...

...and do meyhem behind his back. Then its called SATRATEGY!



nathaniel parker
It's BOOMSDAY!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 17229
Joined: 2005-06-24
From: Always on the move.
Re: Questions for you guys

what the hell does WSYIWIG mean anyways?